Vinyl vs. Concrete vs. Fiberglass Pools: The Ultimate Comparison Guide for Georgia Homeowners

Thinking about adding a pool to your backyard? You’re not alone—Savannah homeowners are diving into the idea now more than ever. But before you start dreaming of floaty cocktails and cannonballs, there’s one big decision to make: What kind of pool should you get—vinyl, concrete, or fiberglass?

At Architectural Pools & Spas of Savannah, we’ve installed pools of every shape, size, and style, and we specialize in fiberglass because it consistently checks the most boxes for our customers. That said, every type of pool has its pros and cons. Here’s a no-fluff breakdown to help you choose what’s right for your home, your lifestyle, and your long-term budget.

Concrete Pools

The classic option with a custom twist

✅ Pros:

Fully customizable in shape, size, and depth
Durable and long-lasting with proper maintenance
Can accommodate unique water features, infinity edges, and beach entries

❌ Cons:

Long installation time (3–6 months is common)
Requires regular resurfacing every 10–15 years
Porous surface = higher chemical use and frequent scrubbing
Rough texture can be uncomfortable on skin

Best for:

Homeowners with large budgets and patience for longer builds who want ultra-custom designs.

Vinyl Liner Pools

Budget-friendly but high maintenance

✅ Pros:

Lower upfront cost
Quicker installation than concrete
Smooth surface

❌ Cons:

Liners need to be replaced every 5–9 years
Easily punctured or torn (especially with pets or rowdy kids)
Limited design flexibility—mostly rectangular or standard shapes
Can fade or wrinkle over time

Best for:

Budget-conscious buyers who want a basic, short-term pool solution.

Fiberglass Pools

Low maintenance, fast install, long-term value

✅ Pros:

Quick installation—often in just 2–3 weeks
Smooth, non-porous surface = fewer chemicals, less cleaning
Built-in features like tanning ledges, steps, and benches
Extremely durable—can last 25+ years with minimal upkeep
Resists algae and staining better than other pool types
Ideal for Georgia's sandy soil and high water tables

❌ Cons:

Limited to pre-molded shapes and sizes (though there are hundreds to choose from)
Not ideal for extreme custom designs

Best for:

Busy families, first-time pool owners, and anyone who wants a sleek, low-maintenance pool without sacrificing style.

⚖️ Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Fiberglass	Concrete	Vinyl
Upfront Cost	$$$	$$$$	$$
Installation Time	4-6 Weeks	3-6 Months	2-3 Weeks
Maintenance Needs	Low	High	Medium - High
Lifespan	30+ Years	30+ Years	5-9 Years (Liner)
Surface Feel	Ultra Smooth	Rough	Smooth
Customizability	Pre-Designed	Fully Custom	Limited
Algae Resistance	High	Low	Medium

Associated Cost of Ownership	Fiberglass	Concrete	Vinyl
Acid Washing (3-5 Years)	-	2 x $450 = $900	-
Pool Cleaning ($500/Season)	-	10 x $500 = $5000	-
Replace Pool Interior	-	Approx $10,000	-
Replace Liner (5-9 Years)	-	-	Approx $4500
Chemical Usage	$1,750 ($175x10)	$7,500 ($750x10)	$4,000 ($400 x10)
Electric Usage	$2,000 (200x10)	$4,000 ($400x10)	$3,000 ($300x10)
10 - Year Cost of Ownership	$3,750	$27,400.00	$11,500

📂Download Barrier Reefs Pool Comparison and FAQs

💡 Why We Recommend Fiberglass for Most Homeowners

Here in Savannah, fiberglass pools are a perfect fit. The weather, the soil, and even the tree pollen all play better with fiberglass than other pool types. You’ll spend less time cleaning, less money on chemicals, and more time enjoying the water.

Plus, with models like the Whitsunday (featuring built-in loungers) and Outback Escape (perfect for small yards or cocktail pool lovers), you can still get a luxury look without the custom-concrete price tag.